Robben or Robin Van Persie?

[Yung Fly + Flashy]

Robben or Robin? Been debating with my bredrin about this today, who would you rather have in your team? *predicts this will turn into a Arsenal fans vs everyone else thread*

[King Poetic]

A fully fit in form Robben playing for Liverpool would bring us closer to the top 2.Hnece Robben.

[Murderous]

Both can be match winners. Im unsure coz neither of them can stay fit long enough to prove it over a whole season. How many games did Robben play in 04/05?I think RVP is more versatile. At their best I would say their about equal, slightly favouring RVP coz of his goal threat.Would depend on the system over who I would prefer.

[Buc Nasty]

This was RvP season till he broke his foot, was on a rampage. would've finished top scorer if he was fit.Robben constant injuries f*ck him up, but can change a game in an instant. dives like bitch though

[M.Dot]

I'm biassed so I wasn't going to answer(Van Persie obviously).But then, remember the world cup...I reckon Kuyt would choose Van Persie.Robben was over greedy and ruined opportunities for kuyt/rvp by going for goal or holding onto the ball too long...when they probably would have scored(being in better positions) if he just played the right ball instead of going for goal.If I was Kuyt I'd prefer Van Persie.Robben is sick but he did wrong when he was on the ball in that trio, IMO.

[Dizzle]

RVPFreekicksCreativityUnpredictabiltyShot techniqueRobbens sick aswell tho

[Medic]

Robben is quality, when he's not diving cheating etc. I'd have v.Persie though...

[King Poetic]

Robben on form is a top 3 left winger in the world.I remember in his first season at Chelsea, before injuries kicked in, people were saying that he was on course to be the player of the season.Him and Duff were murking on the flanks.He is a prick though.

[darkman]

Van Persie, a all round better player.

[Mr Invincible 49]

Van Persie, a all round better player.

[Glock]

Robben when he's not being greedy or diving. Reminds me of C Ronaldo.Van Persie is nang though, had he not been injured this season he would have got a bag of goals.

[Gundam]

Would rather have Robben on my left wing than RVP as my striker.

[FreeMason]

Persie!

[McLovin' Jones]

All depends on the system really but RVP is a better all-round playerPlus, when he gets older and no longer has some of his pace, his all-round technique, creativity can still do damage..I can't predict how Robben will turn out but I don't how effective he'll be when he loses his pace

[Turkish]

RVP has everything over Robben bar the pace so RVP for me. Robben is sick though but RVP shines mroe for Holland also.

[Lenny]

Van Persie, a all round better player.

butwhen robben is on top form,he is unstoppable.his direct running,his dribbling accuracy+the speed he runs at aswell as his balance. he also is a neat finisher when clear on goal.as a winger he is f*cking sickso 4 a team i would pick him over RVPthis time last year this would have been a stupid question,RVP has shown a lot more but not enough yet

[Tom]

I'm biased...v.Persie

[BATTY BOY BUM BANDIT]

Robben.By quite a way. One of the best players in the world. Underrated.

[TF/S4DK]

Robben not a bad player, but you know who I'd rather have...

[Young £]

Robben.By quite a way. One of the best players in the world. Underrated.

[Nah Blud I]

Robben.By quite a way. One of the best players in the world. Underrated.

[XcalibA]

not an easy question to answer cos on there day they are both unstoppable but lookin back on the world cup wen they was both on the same team wud have to say rvp brings da team together better then robben

[mich]

RVP has everything over Robben bar the pace so RVP for me. Robben is sick though but RVP shines mroe for Holland also.

[Libertine]

didnt even have to think about this 1robben